🚚 Free Worldwide Shipping on All Orders!
Shop Now
✕
Cart (0)
Mustard
Award Winners
Specialty Food
Snacks & Charcuterie
Gifts
Merch
Toys & Games
Top Sellers
Home
Store
Pet Toys
Filters
Sort:
Latest Arrivals
Price
Min
-
Max
Apply
Collections
2026 World-Wide Mustard Competition Winners
Garlic, Herb & Veggie Mustard
Hot Pepper Mustard
Honey & Syrup
2014 World-Wide Mustard Competition Winners
Foreign Mustard
Cutting Boards
American & Deli Mustard
Novelties
2023 World-Wide Mustard Competition Winners
Home Goods
2016 World-Wide Mustard Competition Winners
2019 World-Wide Mustard Competition Winners
Exotic Mustard
2022 World-Wide Mustard Competition Winners
2018 World-Wide Mustard Competition Winners
Kitchen & Dining
2015 World-Wide Mustard Competition Winners
Art & Office Supplies
2024 World-Wide Mustard Competition Winners
Pet Toys
Sort:
Latest Arrivals
Pet Toys | National Mustard Museum
NEW
Fred Howligans Toast Distract-O-Mat Lick Mat
$12.95
Quick View
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - DUUUUUUDE
$11.99
Quick View
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Meet the Zoomies
$11.99
Quick View
-65%
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Asshole Cat
$11.99
$4.20
Quick View
-65%
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Your Cat is High
$11.99
$4.20
Quick View
-65%
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Check Out My Butthole
$11.99
$4.20
Quick View
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Precious Angel Baby
$11.99
Quick View
-65%
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Existential Kitty
$11.99
$4.20
Quick View
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Never Trust Your Tail
$11.99
Quick View
NEW
Blue Q Catnip Toy - Talk To Your Kittens About Catnip
$11.99
Quick View
